Is a merchant cash advance a loan? How New York courts decide
A cash advance is written as a sale of future revenue, so lending limits do not apply to it. The three questions New York courts ask to decide whether it is really a loan.
Published
The contract says the funder is buying a share of your future sales at a discount. It does not say loan, interest or rate. That wording is the point: laws that cap interest apply to loans, and a true purchase of future revenue is not one. Whether your agreement is what it says it is can decide whether it can be enforced at all.
Many cash advance contracts choose New York law, and New York's courts have written much of the case law. This is how they approach the question.
Why the label matters
In New York, charging interest above 25% a year on a loan is criminal usury (Penal Law § 190.40). An advance with a 1.4 factor rate repaid over six months costs far more than that when it is worked out as an annual rate; the MCA cost calculator does the arithmetic. If the deal is a purchase, the cap does not apply. If a court decides it is a loan, it does.
The question: is repayment absolute?
A loan has to be repaid whatever happens to the business. A purchase of future sales is paid out of those sales, so if the business fails honestly, the buyer loses. In LG Funding v United Senior Properties of Olathe (2020), a New York appeals court said courts usually weigh three things to tell which one an agreement is:
- Is there a reconciliation provision? One that lets the business have its payments adjusted to its real sales points to a purchase. One that leaves any adjustment to the funder's sole discretion does not.
- Is there a finite term? A purchase is repaid as fast or as slowly as sales come in, with no end date. A fixed daily amount over a fixed number of days looks like a loan schedule.
- Is there recourse if the business goes bankrupt? If bankruptcy or simply being unable to pay is a default that makes everything due, including from the owner personally, the funder is not carrying the risk a buyer carries.
In that case the court let the business's usury defense go forward. It also held that usury can be raised as a defense to the funder's claim but not as a claim of the business's own.
What happened when the state tested it
- In 2024 a New York court entered a judgment of more than $77 million against Richmond Capital Group and related companies for usury and fraud. The Attorney General's office described advances that came close to 4,000% a year once fees and a ten-day repayment were counted, and an earlier ruling in the case canceled the businesses' outstanding debts.
- In 2025 the Attorney General announced a $1.065 billion judgment by settlement against 25 Yellowstone companies. The office said the contracts promised payments tied to revenue and a reconciliation process, while the companies debited fixed daily amounts and almost never adjusted them, at rates of up to 820% a year.
What this does not mean
- Many advances are upheld. Courts enforce agreements whose reconciliation clause is real and whose terms leave the funder with the risk of slow sales.
- The contract is half the answer. How the funder acted counts: whether it honored a reconciliation request, whether the debit ever changed, what it did when sales fell. Keep those records.
- Other states differ. A growing number of states now require cost disclosures for sales-based financing whatever it is called; each state page says what applies and gives its source.
- It is a defense, raised in a case. No form or letter turns an advance into a loan. A court does, on the facts, usually after the funder sues.
What to check in your own agreement
Find the reconciliation section and read who decides. Look for a stated term or a fixed number of payments. Read the default section for bankruptcy, insolvency or "inability to pay". Then compare the contract to your bank statements: has the amount debited ever moved with your sales?
The free Debt Check puts your remittances next to your revenue and counts the advances that are stacked, which is the first thing a lawyer will ask for. Nothing here is legal advice, and this area of law is changing; whether a defense fits your contract is a question for a lawyer who handles these cases.
Sources
- LG Funding, LLC v United Senior Props. of Olathe, LLC, 181 AD3d 664 (2d Dept 2020) (New York Official Reports)
- New York Penal Law § 190.40, criminal usury in the second degree (New York State Senate)
- New York Attorney General, Historic Judgment Against Predatory Lender (February 8, 2024)
- New York Attorney General, $1 Billion Settlement with Predatory Lender (January 22, 2025)



